Community Newsletter
Archives
Archives
September was a month defined by courtroom success stories, continuing efforts to deliver justice to local crime victims in the face of federal interference, and a warning about the tragic results of domestic violence. Your September 2025 Community Newsletter has arrived.
On September 8, the community learned of a deadly domestic violence incident that left both the victim and abuser dead after an initial appearance decision exposed the victim to peril. In response to the tragedy, County Attorney Conover held a press conference with the media to discuss the importance of knowing the signs of abuse.
” A defendant that our office was prosecuting for two felony cases regarding domestic violence strangulation is now reported to have killed the same victim and then killed himself. This is a reminder of how very dangerous and complex domestic violence cases can be,” Pima County Attorney Laura Conover said following the incident. “In this case, we argued and secured a bond to keep him in jail, but the defendant returned to court asking for a second chance to be released. We strenuously objected due to our grave concerns that the defendant’s violence was escalating.”
However, the decision was made to release the defendant in what the state regards as a misdemeanor offense, allowing the abuser to end both of their lives.
When the current administration arrived at PCAO, we changed the Initial Appearance Recommendation form to include a critical warning from the National Institute of Health to emphasize the potential for loss of life in the aftermath of strangulation events between domestic partners.
“This case involves intimate partner strangulation. There is a high lethality associated with Domestic Violence Strangulation,” Conover said. “Forty-three percent of all women who are murdered have been previously strangled by their partner. When a person has been strangled by their partner, there is an 800% increase in the likelihood of that person being murdered.”
County Attorney Conover has vowed to work with Arizona lawmakers to change domestic violence strangulation incidents from misdemeanor to felony cases to ensure that victims are protected from their abusers.
County Attorney Conover speaking to the media about the dangers of domestic violence and resources for victims.
Guilty Except Insane Ruling
Another challenge in prosecution arises when a plea of Guilty Except Insane is made, placing the responsibility for a just sentencing in the hands of the court. In the case of Malyn Pavolka, accused of causing a traffic collision that claimed five lives in October 2024, an initial plea of not guilty was replaced with a Guilty Except Insane plea, which is allowed by Arizona law. That law gives the judge presiding over the case authority to impose a sentence, and the decision was made to commit the defendant to 30 years in an Arizona State Mental Health Institution, the maximum penalty allowed in the case.
Our office continued to work diligently on victim services to provide the family a voice in the case within the confines of this judicial process, protect their rights, and help prevent future harm in our community.
More from the Courthouse
Our prosecutors were successful in many significant criminal trials in September, including several that we celebrated on our social media platforms with “Justice Alerts.” Here are details on those cases:
A second-degree murder conviction of Taton Michael Blade Dorfman for the shooting death of his girlfriend and her dog in 2024. Click here to learn more about that case.
Conviction on 17 counts of sexual exploitation of a minor and one count of surreptitious recording against Whytte Dragun Duncan. To read more, click here.
Successful prosecution of Rosalio Monge Jr. for forgery, fraud schemes, and theft in connection with stealing a check for $5,640.36 that was written to a local home improvement store. To learn more, click here.
County Attorney Laura Conover and members of her team joined a host of other local officials for the opening of CODAC’s new Trauma Recovery Center at 1600 N. Country Club Road. The opening of the new center provides vital services to survivors of violent crime who need support, especially in underserved communities.
Laura joined Pima County Supervisor Andres Cano, Pima County Health Department Director Dr. Theresa Cullen, and CODAC officials for the ribbon-cutting ceremony and to share information about the importance of the new center’s services.
For more information about services provided by CODAC, click here.
The Pima County Attorney’s Office is proud to have one of our veteran prosecutors selected to serve on the Pima County Superior Court bench. Mark Hotchkiss, a 15-year veteran prosecutor at PCAO who most recently supervised our Major Crimes Bureau, began his tenure on the bench in the Pima County Superior Drug Court.
That division of the Pima County Superior Court includes presiding over a broad range of criminal cases as well as specialty courts such as Substance Use, Mental Health Response Team (SMRT), and the Supportive Treatment and Engagement Program (STEPS).
Mark was selected from a pool of 12 applicants, six of whom were interviewed for the position. We wish Mark all the best in his new role in the criminal justice system and are thankful for all the years of delivering justice at PCAO on behalf of the people of Pima County.
An Important Conversation
County Attorney Conover and Communications Director Shawndrea Thomas joined Supervisor Andrés Cano and local leaders to discuss the need for funding domestic violence programs and how the impact of lost funding can be discussed without county supervisors to help supplement the needs of our community. The two-hour-long session also focused on prioritizing funding needs and creative ways to navigate today’s funding challenges. The meeting was held at the Pima County Health Department more than 20 people participated in the event. More meetings and discussions to find solutions are expected in the coming months.
We recruit legal researchers, litigators, and professional staff who use their unique talents to move our Office forward. You’re invited to apply to work for a progressive prosecuting agency that values accountability, public service, and outcome-driven thinking.
We offer excellent work-life balance, great incentives, and a generous benefits package, including:
All open PCAO positions APPLY HERE
There are a variety of positions to apply for at PCAO
Here’s a look at some of the links to social media and podcast messages we’ve shared throughout the year.
All Podcast episodes are available here:
https://thepeoplesofficepodcast.podbean.com/
Social Media Posts:
Happy Constitution Day
PCAO held a fun baby shower for our new Finance Director, Chris Hernandez. We had food, fun, and plenty of laughs and smiles.
Baby Hernandez has arrived. The family is doing well. Welcome to the world, Santiago!!!!
The PCAO Community Newsletter is published and distributed monthly.
Have questions or concerns?
You can email us at info@pcao.pima.gov.
And follow us on social media by clicking on any of the icons below.